Evangelical author Philip Yancey asks: What good is God?
December 9th, 2010
01:24 PM ET

Evangelical author Philip Yancey asks: What good is God?

Philip Yancey, a popular evangelical author, was driving on a deserted road in New Mexico one Sunday morning when something went wrong.

His Ford Explorer hit a patch of black ice and fish-tailed. Yancey wrestled with the steering wheel, but his SUV tumbled over an embankment, shattering glass, plastic and metal - and much of Yancey’s thin body.

He was rushed to a hospital where he was strapped to a gurney for seven hours. A young doctor finally approached him with bad news:  Yancey’s neck was broken and a bone fragment may have nicked a major artery.

“I must emphasize this is a life-threatening situation,” the doctor told Yancey. “Here’s a phone. You may want to contact your loved ones and tell them goodbye…”

Yancey lived to write another day. But the questions he asked himself as he made those phone calls three years ago hang over his latest book, “What Good is God?”

Yancey traveled to some of the grimmest locations in the world to ask people who had been broken in body and spirit the same question: Does belief in God really matter when life gets tough?

Their answers form the heart of his new book. The people Yancey profiled included former prostitutes trying to escape the sex trade in Thailand, leaders in the underground church in China, and members of Alcoholics Anonymous.

Yancey has sold an estimated 14 million books by asking tough questions. In books such as, “What’s So Amazing about Grace,” and “The Jesus I Never Knew,” he has appealed to people who have either been scarred by organized religion or are  skeptical of it.

Yancey, who tells the story of his accident in his new book, recently talked to CNN. His comments were edited for brevity.

CNN: In your book, you say your near-death experience forced you to think of three questions: Who will I miss, how have I spent my life, and am I ready for what happens next? Are those questions still guiding your approach to life?

Yancey: I would like to report that I have since reordered my life around those three questions, but let’s be honest, many days it’s all I can do to answer email and check items off my to-do list.  The ultimate questions get pushed aside.

I have made a deliberate effort, though, to spend time reflecting on those issues.  I begin each day with a time of prayer and meditation, and ask myself how the tasks that await me that day stack up against those three questions.

Also, I have an enduring sense of gratitude—for life, for beauty, for simple things I used to take for granted.  Two years after my accident my brother had a stroke, and I’m reminded constantly of what he can no longer do: walk without a cane, use his right hand on a computer keypad.  I faced the possibility of permanent paralysis from my broken neck; how different my life would be.

CNN: You reported that one Thai prostitute said, “It’s not easy to be healed.” Why did her comment stay with you enough to write about it?

Yancey: I grew up in a Southern Gospel environment rife with testimonies of drunks, addicts, and atheists miraculously transformed by going forward at a tent revival meeting.

Yes, that does sometimes happen.  Over time, though, I’ve learned that not everyone who needs healing—from addiction to sex or drugs, for instance—finds the strength and courage to seek it.  And not everyone who claims healing sticks with it.

The comment by the Thai prostitute reminded me that the moral life, even for a person deeply connected to God, involves constant and ongoing struggle.  Especially when you’ve lived a life of degradation like hers, how do you keep the past from invading the present?

CNN: How is the practice of Christianity different in China than in the U.S.?

Yancey: At my church, when something bad happens, people immediately ask God to fix it: get me a job, heal my aunt, whatever.  I pray those same prayers, and I see nothing wrong with them.  In China, though, I heard different prayers, not “God, take away this burden,” but “God, give me the strength to bear this burden.”

In a country like ours, which has freedom of religion, we can easily take it for granted, either by ignoring it or by going to church as a social habit.

In China, where you can be arrested and imprisoned for your faith, getting together with other Christians is a lifeline and you’ll risk anything for the privilege.  No one attends church in China casually, or for a social advantage—quite the opposite.

I once heard someone from a former Soviet country say that Christians there are praying for the return of oppression because under Communist days the church was pure and refined.

CNN: What can churches learn from AA?

Yancey: Two lessons stand out sharply to me: radical honesty and radical dependence.

Alcoholics Anonymous members can spot a fraud, hypocrite, or liar the minute he or she walks in the door.  They know the only path to healing begins with a frank self-assessment of failure.

When we go to church we like to look good and gain the respect of others.  A married couple may fight all the way to church, but when they pull into the parking lot they’re all smiles, “We’re just fine, Mrs. Jones, how about you?”  You’d never get away with that at AA.

AA also forces each person to admit their dependence on God (or at least a Higher Power) and on each other.  Most AA members freely admit they could never make it on their own.  People of faith believe that, too, yet how many of us practice it as passionately as those in a twelve-step group?

- CNN Writer

Filed under: Belief • Books • Christianity • Jesus

soundoff (1,063 Responses)
  1. John

    I've worked in an ER as a RN as well as now working in a hospital with a Level One trauma department. This story is very unlikely. If Phillip Yancey really had a spinal injury in the manner suggested he would not only have a cervical immobilizer in place but probably not been allowed to move enough to be able to manipulate a cell phone. Next the story will no doubt change to say the doctor took the time to hold the phone (in a busy ER).
    I've had my fill of the Christian narcissistic, big mouthed super authors who write book after book claiming to have God's intentions cornered. Poor Phillip, I wonder how many earth shattering dramas life or God have handed him. I suppose he will write a book about each one.

    January 23, 2014 at 1:45 am |
  2. meizitang soft gel

    I have been getting these capsules for six times now and have shed about 4 lbs which is quicker than I've ever missing bodyweight with diet/exercise by yourself. Via the way, I'm 6ft female who weighs about 210 lbs. I tend to lose 3 or 4 lbs during my first 7 days of a eating plan and training regimen. (I also tend to use a lot drinking water fat.) Since starting these supplements, Ive been undertaking cardio for 30 mins a working day (step aerobics or speed walking) and having plenty of fruits, veggies, and wholegrains. I observe the instructions accordingly and choose the pills on an empty belly and am consuming plenty of water afterward. I've had 1 small headache which completely went absent following consuming a glass of drinking water so I guess its important to stay pretty hydrated on this things. meizitang soft gel http://hongkys.blox.pl/html

    May 3, 2013 at 1:46 am |
  3. interesting blog to read

    I was suggested this web site through my cousin. I'm not positive whether or not this post is written by him as nobody else understand such designated about my difficulty. You're wonderful! Thank you!

    April 22, 2013 at 7:39 am |
  4. Sonia

    Loved this talk. Amazing how an idea can be born in a diner in brooklyn and with tenitacy and faith, it can grow up into what it is today.Thanks for sharing these talks online with us folks that can't make it in person!

    September 6, 2012 at 6:00 pm |
  5. Pam Bartlett

    I have been reading your books for a good few years now and have wanted to say how much I appreciate your take on many issues. I managed to find a copy of "Finding God in unexpected places" and today I read "Running away from fugitives". I tryly think you are right about God's view of nations and I think we are living in very exciting times. I have to ask Him what he is up to as he surveys the turmoil and brings all sorts of people to places where they can hear the Gospel and has organised all the electronic mediums to get His word out there. Keep writing please.

    May 19, 2012 at 7:41 am |
  6. series episodes online

    An all around great blog post!!!

    December 12, 2011 at 9:32 pm |
  7. création sites

    Probably this blogs best read I have ever seen..

    December 10, 2011 at 10:47 am |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
About this blog

The CNN Belief Blog covers the faith angles of the day's biggest stories, from breaking news to politics to entertainment, fostering a global conversation about the role of religion and belief in readers' lives. It's edited by CNN's Daniel Burke with contributions from Eric Marrapodi and CNN's worldwide news gathering team.