March 27th, 2011
01:00 AM ET
In key American Muslim enclave, alienation is growing
Editor’s note: The original version of this story omitted the fact that the attorney for Roger Stockham, who was charged with making terrorist threats against a Dearborn mosque, says his client is a Muslim convert.
By Dan Gilgoff, CNN.com Religion Editor
Madison Heights, Michigan (CNN) - Dawud Walid asked the worshipers for a show of hands: How many had heard about the Muslim radicalization hearings in Washington earlier that day?
About half of the 50 or so Muslims in the banquet hall-turned-mosque indicated that they had.
So Walid, executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations’ Michigan chapter, briefed the other half about the hearing, calling it an “unfortunate first in American history.”
Then he went further, warning about what he said were a handful of growing threats to American Muslims.
“As we approach the 10th anniversary of September 11, we are seeing unprecedented acts of Islamophobia,” Walid told the worshipers at the American Islamic Community Center, 10 miles north of Detroit.
“After 9/11, it was coming from a few right-wingers,” he said. “But now, in 2011, we’re seeing it from Congress.”
Walid went on to tell the congregation that a dozen states - from Georgia to Missouri to New Mexico - are considering bans on Sharia, or Islamic law, and warned that such bans could lead to prohibitions on women wearing the hijab, or headscarf, and even on Muslims worshiping Allah.
“Praying five times a day is Sharia,” he said. “Do you go to jail for that?”
As one of the largest and oldest Muslim enclaves in the nation - and, with its century-old ties to Ford Motor Co., one that’s intimately bound up in the modern American story - the metro Detroit community is perhaps as close as one can get to the soul of American Islam.
At a time when the country is wrestling with its views on Islam, the faith causes relatively little friction in the largely Arab cocoon of southeast Michigan.
But narratives playing out in the national media, from the radicalization hearings spearheaded by New York Republican Rep. Peter King to the wave of proposed Sharia bans to anticipation of the September 11 anniversary, have left many Muslims here feeling ostracized in their own country.
The community is growing more defensive in the face of what many here say is a national climate of suspicion reminiscent of the period immediately after the 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
In response to what he called “a spike in anti-Muslim bigotry,” Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Illinois, is holding a Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing Tuesday on “measures to protect the rights of American Muslims.”
Witnesses will include Roman Catholic Cardinal Theodore McCarrick - the former archbishop of Washington - and the top civil rights officials from the administrations of Barack Obama and George W. Bush.
On this Thursday night, however, worshipers at the American Islamic Community Center echoed the embattled tone of the guest speaker from Center for American-Islamic Relations.
Hadir Ghazala, a 49-year-old Iraqi immigrant in a black-and-white polka-dot hijab, said she’d been turned down for jobs at local salons because she refused to remove her headscarf.
Mohammed Elzhemni, 39, bemoaned what he called a growing national stereotype of Muslims as terrorists.
“These people raise their families and work hard,” he said, gesturing to a cluster of small children chasing each other across the mosque’s faux marble floor. “I’m a manager at GM and work to make the country better. This is the true face of Islam.”
At a time when King and others are alleging that radical American Muslims pose an under-acknowledged threat to national security, a popular refrain among Detroit-area Muslims is that they’re the ones under attack.
The sentiment is especially acute at the Islamic Center of America, which calls itself the nation’s largest mosque.
This year, police said they thwarted an explosives attack on the house of worship in Dearborn, just west of Detroit city limits. In January, police arrested a man in the center’s parking lot in a car they said was packed with fireworks.
Police said the suspect, Roger Stockham, drove to Dearborn from California. He faces two felony charges carrying maximum sentences of up to 20 years.
The arrest provoked state and local law enforcement agencies to urge the 70,000-square-foot mosque to bolster security and develop a new emergency response plan.
“We’ve never had an incident like that, where we were targeted by someone who wanted to do us harm based on who we are,” said Kassem Allie, the center’s executive administrator.
To Allie, the incident is evidence that some Americans are being radicalized against Islam, turning the allegation of growing Muslim radicalization on its head.
“The suspect was apparently radicalized quite some time ago,” Allie said. “And there are other instances of radicalization that are of great concern to us.
“I have no problem addressing Islamic radicalization,” he said, monitoring the mosque's security cameras from a computer screen in his ground-floor office. “But there should be an acknowledgment that other communities have the same problem.”
Indeed, a common complaint around Dearborn, the epicenter of southeast Michigan’s Muslim community, is that the only time religion is mentioned in a crime story is when the suspect is Muslim.
“When Timothy McVeigh did his bombing, we didn’t investigate or blame Christianity,” said Al Machy, 32, referring to the 1995 attack on a federal building in Oklahoma City that left 168 dead.
Machy works behind the counter at the Golden Bakery on Warren Avenue, a miles-long Dearborn strip lined with halal butchers, hookah bars, Lebanese restaurants and locally owned groceries with names like Baghdad Market and Sahara West. Signs for most businesses are in Arabic.
“Every day, there are hundreds of rapes and murders, and they never put the words 'Christian' or 'Jewish' in the story,” said Machy, an Iraqi refugee who arrived in the U.S. after the Gulf War.
Unlike most such crimes, in which religion doesn’t appear to be an issue, recent instances of homegrown terrorism - such as 2009’s Fort Hood shooting and last year’s failed Times Square bomb plot - were allegedly carried out in the name of Islam.
But many Muslims around Dearborn say those cases garner inordinate news attention while recent attacks against Muslim Americans, including the defacing and burning of mosques, are largely neglected.
According to the Justice Department, there were 107 anti-Muslim hate-crime incidents in 2009, the most recent year for which statistics are available, compared with 28 such incidents in 2000.
After a sharp spike in 2001, when there were 481 anti-Muslim hate crime incidents, there have since been fewer than 200 such incidents annually, though there were generally fewer than 50 in the years before 2001.
Muslim advocacy groups, including the Council on American-Islamic Relations, say they have seen a more recent uptick in anti-Muslim threats and violence.
Officials at the Islamic Center of America, which draws about 1,200 worshipers for Friday prayers, say local law enforcement encouraged them to take a low-key public stance on the January explosives arrest. Authorities wanted to avoid inspiring copycat attacks or reprisals, mosque officials said.
The mosque issued a news release after the suspect’s arrest but limited its interviews with the media. Chuck Alawan, 80, a founding board member of the mosque, has some regrets about the mosque keeping relatively quiet about the incident.
“You never hear about all the threats against mosques,” Alawan said in the thick Midwestern accent of a lifelong Michigan resident.
“I was born in this country, and I have never felt persecuted,” he said. “But it’s getting close to that.”
As Alawan spoke, a surveyor from the Michigan Department of Transportation was setting up equipment on the mosque’s lawn as part of a “vulnerability study” after the January incident.
Last week, the Islamic Center of America learned that the Florida pastor who triggered an international firestorm last year by threatening to burn the Quran would take part in an April protest at the mosque.
The protest against "Sharia and Jihad" is scheduled for Good Friday, two days before Easter.
"It is necessary that we set very clear lines for Muslims that are here in America,” Terry Jones, the Florida pastor, said in a statement Wednesday announcing his plans to protest at the Dearborn mosque. "If they desire to change our Constitution, in other words to institute Sharia, then these Muslims are no longer welcome in our country."
Officials at the Islamic Center of America are still deciding how to respond, though they are leaning toward a Good Friday counter-event that would bring together religious leaders of different backgrounds to encourage tolerance and interfaith dialogue.
"For us to try to fight fire with fire like in this case - to fight hate with hate - is really unproductive and actually destructive," said Allie, the mosque's executive administrator. "Under different circumstances, we'd welcome a dialogue with Terry Jones or other detractors, but it's got to be civilized."
Developments like the mosque protest have some local law enforcement officials sympathizing with growing Muslim anxiety.
Dearborn Police Chief Ronald Haddad is among them. He estimates that he has received 10,000 anti-Muslim “hate e-mails,” some calling him a “Taliban police chief” or alleging that he’s persecuting Christians.
The senders assume he’s Muslim because of his last name, Haddad says, even though he’s a Christian of Lebanese descent.
Like Alawan and Haddad, many Arab-Americans in the area trace their local roots back generations. The first big wave of Middle Easterners arrived in southeast Michigan around 1910 to man Henry Ford’s automobile plants in Highland Park and Dearborn.
Those immigrants were mostly Christians from the area that is now Lebanon but was then part of the Ottoman Empire.
“Ford seemed to think that that this particular segment of the empire was industrious and productive and a good source of cheap labor,” said Saeed Khan, a lecturer in Islamic history, politics and culture at Wayne State University in Detroit.
Khan said Ford also favored immigrants from that region because, unlike some other groups, they tended to be light-skinned.
After the defeated Ottoman Empire was carved up at the end of World War I, Christians were given favored status in the newly created Lebanon, provoking more Muslims to exit the region. Some wound up in new Arab strongholds like metro Detroit.
“Especially after Henry Ford announced the $5 workday, (immigrants) would get off the train in Detroit looking for work, and police would pick them up and take them to Ford’s Rouge plant to apply,” Dearborn Mayor John O’Reilly said, referring to a huge Dearborn manufacturing facility that opened in the 1920s.
Today, southeast Michigan’s Muslim population is estimated at nearly half a million, Khan said. Though there are larger Muslim populations in New York and Southern California, there are few places in the country with such a heavy concentration of Muslims.
“Once Henry Ford established that community, it had a pull effect and became an epicenter of Arab life,” Khan said. “It was influenced by employment opportunities and the availability of resources like mosques and schools.”
Though Dearborn retains its Lebanese flavor, the area’s Muslim community includes many immigrants from India, Pakistan, Yemen and elsewhere, along with a growing Eastern European contingent and many African-Americans.
The historic Muslim presence here helps explain why local allegations of Islamophobia are pretty rare - and why Haddad, the police chief, suspects that most of his anti-Muslim e-mail is from outsiders.
Zeinab Dbouk-Chaayto, a recent immigrant from Lebanon, says that she was the only woman donning a hijab when she took classes recently at Madonna University, a Catholic school in Livonia, just west of Dearborn, but that no one gave her any trouble.
The school’s conservative culture jibed with her Muslim values. “There’s no partying and no alcohol,” she said, adding that administrators in a school office where she worked even threw her a baby shower and a birthday party.
Local law enforcement officials, for their part, say they strengthened ties to greater Detroit’s Muslim leadership after September 11, launching a program called Bridges to create an ongoing dialogue between those leaders and the FBI, state and local law enforcement, and other government agencies.
“Sometimes, there’s a relative who feels that someone in the family might be doing things that probably aren’t in the long-term best interest of the country, and they want to bring that forward,” said O’Reilly, the Dearborn mayor, explaining the program.
“But they don’t want to be responsible for throwing a family member in jail,” he said. “There’s a delicacy to that, so they have a dialogue about where people can bring this stuff forward.”
Haddad, the Dearborn police chief, said the Bridges program helped create a parents’ task force to combat gang activity in the city’s Yemeni community. That move contributed to an 11% drop in crime in the heavily Yemeni South End neighborhood last year, he said.
At the same time, many Muslims around Dearborn are convinced that they are under government surveillance, exacerbating feelings of alienation.
Sitting with friends at the Islamic Center of America, Alawan says, they often joke that law enforcement has the mosque’s phones tapped and its rooms bugged.
“The agencies will deny it,” he said. “But we know they’re doing it.”
The suspicion was given credence after FBI agents killed a Muslim cleric in an October 2009 raid in Dearborn.
The charges against the imam, Luqman Ameen Abdullah - which included mail fraud and the illegal possession and sale of firearms - were based on information from three confidential FBI informants who’d infiltrated Abdullah’s mosque.
The case raised the specter of government spies in other Dearborn area mosques and prompted a 2010 letter of protest from Michigan Democratic Rep. John Conyers to U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder.
“People of all faiths should be free to worship without undue fear that the person in the next pew is a government agent,” Conyers wrote, invoking the FBI’s wiretapping of the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. as a regrettable precedent for such surveillance.
Many Muslims around Dearborn find it ironic that what they see as a growing suspicion of Muslims in America comes at a time when much of the Arab world, from Tunisia to Egypt to Libya, is rising up against despotic leaders and demanding more U.S.-style freedoms.
“While the Islamic world is rising up against dictatorship, dishonesty, deception and corruption … America should show solidarity with people who are looking for dignity and democracy,” Imam Mohammad Ali Elahi told hundreds of worshipers at recent Friday prayers at the Islamic House of Wisdom in Dearborn Heights, a mosque situated across the street from Henry Ford Community College.
“That’s not the right time to bring another wave of Islamophobia and ignorance,” he said, blasting the King hearings of the previous day. “It is so dangerous to provoke people who are ready to commit hate crimes with this kind of wrong information.”
Elahi wasn’t referring to the danger of inciting Muslim radicals to commit terrorism against the United States. The threat, in his eyes, is that Americans will be provoked to terrorize Muslims.
About this blog
The CNN Belief Blog covers the faith angles of the day's biggest stories, from breaking news to politics to entertainment, fostering a global conversation about the role of religion and belief in readers' lives. It's edited by CNN's Daniel Burke with contributions from Eric Marrapodi and CNN's worldwide news gathering team.
Very sad this is happening in our own country. I hope one day we can all live in peace.
All religion is evil though, so get over it 🙂
Since we are a nation of so many religeous faiths and none of the others feels so alienated...maybe...just maybe...it's not us.
Haters gonna hate.
Muslims blow up buildings
Christians/catholic priest molest children
Jews are good with money
Religion - pfftt
I wish someone would write about the discrimination and alienation that men who are falsely accused of domestic abuse face in this country. This country has its own discrimination and human rights problems that need fixing before it goes pointing the finger at other countries of human right violations
As a Gay American whose community has been subject to extreme bigotry and violences for centuries in this country, I have zero empathy for these muslims who feel ostracized. If I can chin up, pay my taxes, serve my country, support my country and still not have the same legal rights muslims have, what the allah damned hell is their excuse?
America is the land of the free. People are allowed to practice whatever religion they choose. And, when people disagree with perceived tenets of that religion, they have a right to voice those concerns. But, this is a clear example of scapegoating. Many people are feeling anxious and frustrated–unemployment is high, the nation is in debt, and, the demographics of America are changing. By nature, people search for an easy target to dump their anxiety, fears, and frustration. At this point in history, that target is Muslims. Though I understand people are feeling hurt and afraid, taking out such feelings on a group of law-abiding, hard-working fellow Americans is wrong.
two comments here: Freedom of religion and the word DEARBORN. Infringing in America of all places upon someone's ability to practice their religion is absolutely shameful and saddening beyond belief. Dearborn is the city they are referring to and i am sick of hearing CNN and other news outlets i am sure, referring to Dearborn as Metro Detroit. If Dearborn has suddenly become part of Detroit instead of just outside it's border, please inform all Detroit that there weak census numbers just got a heck of a boost, and that anyone working in Dearborn can now have the privelege of paying the city of Detroit's 1% city income tax which will sure help with Detroits financial woes. Henry Ford estate and headquarters are there.
That is some pretty tricky reporting by CNN. Roger Stockham, the terrorist with the explosives, is a Sunni Muslim convert. Interesting how they left that out of the article and ironic that they would use Muslim-on-Muslim violence as an example of American "radicalization" against Muslims. A very sophist argument...
More from Pat on dangers of Islam :
I love the Bigotry on this subject!! 50% of the US Population is Brainwashed drones.Taking the news only from their FOX news and CNN. Did anyone of you protest a church or congregation for blowing up the Abortion Doctors? Do you consider yourself KKK because it is a Christian Organization? NO?
Do you know that Israel air bombed and killed 1,500 Palestinian civilians just in January of 2009 because they believe that Israel is their promised land and noone has "more" right to live there other than jews? Are you going against the Jewish Americans and their Synagogues ? NO?
Open your closed MINDS!!
Americans are ignorant. There, I said it. Captain Obvious to the rescue!
No sane person would choose to be Muslim. No intellegent person would embrace religion. It's all nonsense.
Many people have and are converting to Islam, like it or not, out of their free will, choice, and because they believe that is the spiritual path for them. Call them what you like, I don't see why we can't accept people following different faiths, I thought this was supposed to be America.
Thanks Wayne, you just redefined the term "Third Grader" for me by showing how stupid you are.
He is correct...but frankly I do not think 3rd graders are so precocious.
The scientific evidence against the supernatural myths of both the Quran and the Bible is staggering. Did you want to parade your marvelous intellect and debate the facts supporting the Quran. Third graders everywhere are watching. Let's go.
How many more terrorist attacks around the world have to happen until we ship these phuckers back to mecca? The fact is, the more islam we allow in this country, the more islamic terrorism there will be!! DUH!!!!!!! They have always hated us well guess what now the feeling is mutual. GO PHUCK YOURSELVES YOU MUSLIM MAGGOTS
I'm sorry you are not American, you must not be since you are against Freedom of religion. So go back to where you came from, or where your grandparents came from, go back to England, you are the exact reason the rest of the world thinks Americans are pigs and idiots, and there you are showing them all that you are.
I agree with Jason. I'm appalled that people here who call themselves "freedom lovers" and claim to be fighting for American values are the same ones who are trying to bring down freedom of worship in America. After the Muslims, who's next? Why is it that every different religion in this country has to be harrassed, questioned and discriminated against whenever it enters our culture? First the Catholics, then the Jews, now the Muslims. For God's sake, isn't this supposed to be the 21st century??
@jason. Tolerance should be a two-way street. How can we tolerate muslims when they don't tolerate us? They are way, way, way more cruel to us than we are to them. Are you a moron or are you due back at the terrorist training camp now?
Just shutup Jason you crybaby....I've served my country (Iraq war vet) and witnessed with my own eyes how these people feel about Americans. Try to question my allegiance to America you muslim sympathizing clown....I'm not against freedom of religion, I'm against a death cult that preaches nothing but death and intolerance towards anybody who is not practicing in that cult and don't want that BS anywhere near my American family and friends. I only hope that you are blown to pieces at the hands of the next muslim homicide bomber so maybe the people in your family will open their eyes to the people that need to STAY OUT OF THE USA.
These Muslims are safer in this country then anywhere else in thr world. if they think they are unsafe here let them leave.
Reading these comments are only a reflection of the ignorance of most people. All religions are of mankind, inspired by the Devil. That's why you all need to come into a personal reality and relationship through revelation of Jesus Christ!!! Remember this again, religion is of the Devil and relationship is from the only true and living God!!!
But isn't Christianity a religion? Isn't worshipping Jesus... religious? Are you saying then, Christianity (a religion) is of the Devil?
So basically what he is saying is we are all evil... Rock on, but no his comment has nothing to do with this. His ignorance is the fact that this isn't about religion... This is about The Racists in America, Just like the Civil Rights movement in the 60's the haters in the world have found a new target, because our government is too stupid to actually find Osama Bin Laden and bring him to justice, so if you can't find the man attack his religion. SOunds like the KKK to me... America is a land of freedom tolerance and freedom of religion, none of which 90% of the people on this thread are showing.
This site has one purpose,to check the pulse of the nation.I ask,who is interested in American people's rights and who is looking out for the majority?We are fighting wars all over the world and they want is dead.Even CNN can not deny this.
It is sad to see so much hate in this country and little education about other cultures and religions. In many instances we "Americans" bring destructions upon ourselfs and we are blind to see why.
The hate is from the muslims. But you don't care about that, do you? Those same muslims that complain about not being liked will cheer when infidels are killed for not being muslim.
@KLS: who's hating who here? There is a large Muslim community near where I live for years and I have nothing but compliments for them. There is good and bad everywhere, but you don't care about that do you? Cool down. I've lived around these people for years, and I welcome Muslims anytime. Right-wing radicals no.
Just look at studies of countries as the population of Muslim rises. Everything gets worse. Violence everywhere, women treated as 2nd class citizens. I'm not sure what is the deal with that religion but the minority extremists seem to dominate all others with violence.
Case in point. I go back to my original post, lack of knowledge and education. That is all I'm going to say. Just wante to share my oppinion, and was proven right at the end :).
For those who agree, thank you, those who dont you have the right. 🙂 PEACE
The fact there is even a "Muslim Enclave" is scary. They already wanted to be separate to not be "polluted by American values". They are really pushing their first amendment right because I am sure the Founding Fathers didn't mean to afford protection to a religion so opposed to our existence as is Islam.
Freedom of religion Joe? Sound familiar? You remember the Declaration of Independence? Apparently not, or you aren't an American. So which is it? If you are an American. then you believe in Freedom of Religion, and yet you are against Freedom of Religion because it doesn't go along with your feelings, so... you have proven that you are against Freedom of Religion, so you must not be an American.
Shortly after the 9/11 attack, I met someone from Detroit who told me of numerous PARTIES that the muslim were having in celebration of the attacks on the USA...
They should have been deported at that time.
To Jason: Death threats are NOT part of religion. You don't have to be an American to know that.
I've been thinkg on what to respod to this, but I find that it is not worth doing so. 911 was a terrible event, many inocent people died, and not only Americans and not only Christians. The actios of a few ALWAS affect the masses. The same can be said about what the USA has done to other countries, but I guess that is another topic.
Poor Muslins is tender story, and I just want to cry. Sorry, Baby can you stop cutting onions!