My Take: Trump a litmus test for GOP
April 25th, 2011
09:10 AM ET

My Take: Trump a litmus test for GOP

Editor's Note: Stephen Prothero, a Boston University religion scholar and author of "God is Not One: The Eight Rival Religions that Run the World," is a regular CNN Belief Blog contributor.

By Stephen Prothero, Special to CNN

I don’t really care whether Donald Trump is running for president. But I am dying to see how Republicans respond to him.

Today’s Republican Party draws on a wide variety of strands, and those strands pull it in different directions. The party’s libertarian roots are visible in Paul Ryan and Rand Paul and other Ayn Rand aficionados who have classically favored maximizing individual freedom by cutting taxes and minimizing government.

Its roots in social conservatism and the Religious Right are visible in Sarah Palin and George W. Bush and their opposition to abortion rights.

These two strands conflict, of course, on questions of gay marriage and marijuana decriminalization - whenever the individual liberty so prized by libertarians bumps up against the efforts favored by social conservatives to Christianize the nation.

Although libertarians seem to be resurgent inside the party (though perhaps only on economic questions), social conservatives have been ascendant for the last generation. Do Republicans want government to stay out of wallets? Yes. Do they want government to stay out of our bedrooms? Not so much.

Another Republican strand, of course, is populism. As its name implies, this "-ism" always involves an appeal to the innate wisdom of the “people” over the book learning of “elites.” But it has often carried class antagonisms as well, championing the interests of working-class Americans over those of the “well bred, well fed, well read and well wed.”

The notion that “The Donald” can appeal to Joe Sixpack seems absurd on its face. But then again so does the notion that Republicans can appeal to ordinary Americans by drawing a line in the sand against allowing today’s marginal tax rate for couples earning over $250,000 a year to return to 36% (from the current 33%).

But Trump's current appeal - a recent CNN poll showed him tied with Mike Huckabee at the top of the GOP heap - does seem rooted more in populism than in social conservatism or libertarianism. Why else would he keep returning to the "birther" question, and to quick-and-easy solutions to our economic problems, such as slapping a 25% tariff on Chinese goods or seizing Iraqi oil?

One of the great ironies of contemporary American politics is that Republicans are now the populist party. Not since the 1930s and Herbert Hoover has any major party been so committed to confusing the business of America with the business of business, but that party (the GOP) is successfully tagging President Obama and the Democrats with engaging in "class warfare." We seem to have forgotten that the class rage underlying populism is supposed to be of the poor against the rich.

A Trump run to the top of the GOP ticket would underscore this irony. It would be the icing on the cake, the fois gras on the steak, the penthouse in Trump Tower. By any metaphor, however, this is a defining moment for the GOP.

The party line on the Tea Party (and not just in Republican circles) has until recently been that its complaints are economic, not social. But these Tea Party partisans look a lot like like the old Religious Right.

Will they be able to embrace a man who has only recently found the true religion they favor?  Will they be able to overlook his prior support for abortion rights and civil unions for gay couples?

In a recent interview on the Christian Broadcasting Network, Trump said, “I believe in God. I am Christian. I think the Bible is certainly, it is THE book. It is the thing." In response to suspicions that he is an Easter and Christmas Christian at best, he also called himself a "Sunday church person."

Will that be convincing to social conservatives and Tea Party activists?  Or will it fall as flat as John Kerry's descriptions of his acolyte service as a teenager?

There are a heavenly host of questions about Donald Trump that we will get to ask and answer if he decides to run for president. But these are the questions his current flirtation raises for me: Is today's Republican Party about jobs or bedroom issues? Is it focused like a laser beam on reducing taxing and spending? Or is it preoccupied with reducing abortions and same-sex marriages?

Thanks to Donald Trump, it looks like we are going to find out.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Stephen Prothero.

- CNN Belief Blog contributor

Filed under: Abortion • Christianity • Opinion • Politics • Tea Party • United States

soundoff (362 Responses)
  1. RightturnClyde

    We get the government you deserve. The founders gave us an incredible nation of freedoms (including a Bill of Rights that was unprecedented in history). It's interesting to see how quickly the anti-Trump liberals went to calling him racist and even personal attacks against his hair and he appearance. Obama's race is he only thing he's had to offer. He trashed the economy, unemployment is well into depression, energy prices are draining wealth, mortgage foreclosures, and he dictated a health care law that will ruin health care. Trump is a successful business leader (like Bill Gates, Warren Buffet or Lee Iacoca). Now you know why those leaders will have no part in leading US. We don't deserve it. We get the government we deserve. Obama is well deserved. You asked for it - you got it.

    May 6, 2011 at 12:23 pm |
  2. TV_Preacher

    Obama's multi-tasking was brilliant! Obama first releases his birth certificate, forcing Trump to call for even more harassment of the President. Then Obama postponed the Bin Laden announcement until it was time for Trumps show to start. After the announcement Obama invites Trump to the press conference, where he squanches Trump so bad, it sent the Republicans straight to hell to find a replacement. GOOD WORK, MR. PRESIDENT! Now ask George where he put the "Mission Accomplished" banner.

    May 3, 2011 at 11:30 am |
  3. Alex B-P

    I like Trump. He's hilarious. He's the only one who doesn't realize that he keeps proving himself wrong, lol.

    May 3, 2011 at 12:43 am |
  4. Addy

    Trump Palin 2012 = NO brains!!

    May 2, 2011 at 7:54 pm |
  5. JW

    New bumper sticker: Trump Palin 2012
    It's A No Brainer!

    May 2, 2011 at 12:01 pm |
  6. wecantbeTHISdumb

    Trump has declared bankruptcy several times; each time leaving hundreds of workers twisting in the wind. His real estate developments that haven't gone bankrupt have consistently underperformed. He is not a great business man, he just plays one on TV. The only business he's been successful in is marketing the Trump name as a brand to properties he has no managerial stake in. Will he keep his promises to "we, the people"? I don't know...ask Ivanka and Marla, they might have the most insight to offer. And he's a Christian?! Believers, please don't believe this one! Didn't Jesus himself say it would be easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than it would be for a rich man to get into heaven?

    April 30, 2011 at 8:35 pm |
    • JR

      LOL! There is no god, dude. Grow up.

      April 30, 2011 at 10:25 pm |
    • Alex B-P

      There is no god.

      May 3, 2011 at 12:41 am |
  7. bdsun1

    Donny T (from what I've seen and heard) is a great business man and even a good family man. When it comes to politics, I don't know how It'll turn out, but if Bloomberg can play the "Public-Servant game," Don should be given a turn at it!

    April 28, 2011 at 4:53 pm |
    • wecantbeTHISdumb

      bdsun1, you ignorant twit: Your boy "Donny T" is not a great business man, he just plays one on TV. None of his "apprentices" have built substantial businesses; that's why he couldn't get enough applicants and had to resort to finding "celebrity" apprentices pulled from the "WAY past their prime" bin. A good family man?!? You might want to check with the 2 former Mrs. Trumps before spreading that idea around.

      April 30, 2011 at 8:47 pm |
  8. DIVA

    Donald Trump is a bully who needs to be stopped. We have laws in schools to stop the bullying but need some for people in business. If President Obama was born in Indonesia or Kenya, Africa, he would not have been able to hide it because the Africans never hide their families. Yes, we would have been glad to claim and would have been screaming it from the roof tops. Donald trump! Where did you go to University? What kind of student were you? Did any of your kids attend college? What about the wives? You cannot be in the white House because it is for men with ONE (1) wife not several wives with different kids. The best thing you can do for yourself is to get a HAIR CUT AND STOP THE PUSH BACK DO OK!

    April 28, 2011 at 2:35 pm |
    • jag

      I wouldn't call Donald a bully. Bullies frighten people. Rush is a bully. Donald is just a fool.

      May 3, 2011 at 11:39 am |
  9. Caroline

    Guessing birthers should vacation elsewhere than Hawaii, but then again they can only afford the Hills of Arkansas or Idaho.

    April 28, 2011 at 5:09 am |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
About this blog

The CNN Belief Blog covers the faith angles of the day's biggest stories, from breaking news to politics to entertainment, fostering a global conversation about the role of religion and belief in readers' lives. It's edited by CNN's Daniel Burke with contributions from Eric Marrapodi and CNN's worldwide news gathering team.