August 3rd, 2012
08:41 AM ET
Chick-fil-A controversy shines light on company’s charitable giving
By Dan Gilgoff, CNN.com Religion Editor
(CNN) - The website for the WinShape Foundation, a group started by Chick-fil-A founder Truett Cathy that’s financed almost entirely by Chick-fil-A profits, doesn’t look like a battlefield in the culture war.
The site features warm and fuzzy snapshots of winding country roads and rustic cabins along with links to a cornucopia of social welfare programs the foundation funds - from foster homes to kids’ camps to college scholarships - that would seem to be the furthest thing from controversial.
The foundation's “simple but profound goal” is also hard to take issue with: “Help ‘shape winners.’ ”
But gay rights groups are incensed about the chain’s financial support for what they say are anti-gay groups. WinShape-backed groups deny that accusation, while WinShape stresses its activities are almost entirely aimed at youth and families, as opposed to conservative advocacy.
Yet WinShape finds itself in the center of a storm over gay rights and religious liberties as Americans take sides in the controversy over Chick-fil-A President Dan Cathy’s recently reaffirmed opposition to same-sex marriage.
CNN’s Belief Blog: The faith angles behind the biggest stories
"We are very much supportive of the family - the biblical definition of the family unit," Dan Cathy, Truett’s son, said in an interview last month. "We are a family-owned business, a family-led business, and we are married to our first wives. We give God thanks for that."
The comments sparked a tsunami of criticism from gay rights advocates and their allies, with a same-sex kiss day at Chick-fil-A restaurants nationwide scheduled for Friday. (Supporters rallied around the chain Wednesday, with an event dubbed Chick-fil-A Appreciation Day.)
But gay rights groups appear even more concerned about Chick-fil-A’s charitable giving, most of which is funneled through WinShape. The group received more than $8 million from Chick-fil-A in 2010, the most recent years for which tax records are available.
A fact sheet about Chick-fil-A recently issued by the Human Rights Campaign, the country’s largest gay rights group, aims its ire mostly at WinShape.
The fact sheet, titled “Chick-fil-A anti-gay: Company funnels millions to anti-equality groups,” says that the “popular fast food chain has donated millions to groups that demonize (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender) people on a daily basis.”
The document enumerates what it calls Chick-fil-A’s “shocking donations” to evangelical groups such as the Fellowship of Christian Athletes and Focus on the Family.
Other gay rights groups have also zeroed in on WinShape’s donations.
A 2011 report from Equality Matters, an arm of the liberal group Media Matters Action Network, said the restaurant’s “charitable division has provided more than $1.1 million to organizations that deliver anti-LGBT messages and promote egregious practices like reparative therapy that seek to ‘free’ people of being gay.”
The WinShape-backed groups that gay rights advocates accuse of being anti-gay reject that label, insisting that they condemn homosexual acts, not gay people.
“Those Christian groups don’t see themselves as hateful organizations - it’s a completely different perspective,” said Rusty Leonard, a financial adviser who counsels Christians on charitable giving and who knows the Cathy family. “But as conservative Christians we believe that homosexual activity is sinful.”
Most WinShape-backed groups, such as Focus on the Family and the Fellowship of Christian Athletes, are mostly apolitical and are mainstream within the evangelical world.
At the same time, the left-leaning Southern Poverty Law Center has classified some WinShape-backed organizations, such as the Family Research Council, as anti-gay hate groups.
WinShape spends the vast majority of its money on internal programs like its camps, which cost $5 million to run in 2010, and foster homes, which cost $3.2 million that year.
By comparison, the organization gave $1,000 to Family Research Council in 2010 and $1,000 to Exodus International, a group that for years promoted so-called conversion therapy for gays, though the group is now reassessing that stance.
“The WinShape Foundation and Chick-fil-A’s corporate giving is focused on supporting youth, family and educational programs,” said Steve Robinson, Chick-fil-A’s executive vice president for marketing, in a statement to CNN.com, responding to questions.
“WinShape provides camping programs for more than 13,000 girls and boys annually and 14 foster homes caring for more than 100 children,” the statement continued. "In addition, Chick-fil-A has awarded more than $30 million in Restaurant Team Member college scholarships to hourly employees.”
A public relations firm representing WinShape and Chick-fil-A declined interview requests Thursday.
WinShape’s own programs have a serious Christian tint. Its summer camp for kids “challenges campers to sharpen their character, deepen their Christian faith and relationships,” according to its website.
The foundation’s college scholarships, mostly for current and former Chick-fil-A employees, are to Berry College, a Christian liberal arts school in Georgia. The scholarships are bent on equipping “college students to impact the world for Jesus Christ by following him and living out his unique calling in their lives,” according to WinShape.
For evangelical Christians, such programs make Chick-fil-A a model corporate citizen.
Follow the CNN Belief Blog on Twitter
“On the conservative end of the Christian world, they are seen as being one of the most fabulous examples of Christianity lived out in appropriate ways,” Leonard said. “They support all kinds of wonderful things.”
But for now, the national focus is on outside groups that WinShape supports. The gay rights group GLAAD, for example, recently started a petition to get Dan Cathy to have dinner with a pair of gay parents and their children.
“If Cathy is going to spend millions trying to break apart loving families,” the petition says, “he should at least meet the people his money is hurting."
About this blog
The CNN Belief Blog covers the faith angles of the day's biggest stories, from breaking news to politics to entertainment, fostering a global conversation about the role of religion and belief in readers' lives. It's edited by CNN's Daniel Burke with contributions from Eric Marrapodi and CNN's worldwide news gathering team.
Seriously – Gays are attacking FCA – I am a proud member – an athlete and a believer in God – all the Gays need to understand the gravity of the fight they picked and you have no idea how many believe in God and marriage between a man and women versus the few freaks that want to complian about marriage – shame on you CNN for publishing these complaining liberal Gays.
You said, "Seriously – Gays are attacking FCA – I am a proud member – an athlete and a believer in God – all the Gays need to understand the gravity of the fight they picked and you have no idea how many believe in God and marriage between a man and women versus the few freaks that want to complian about marriage – shame on you CNN for publishing these complaining liberal Gays."
Considering that you're the adult who still believes in fairy tales, I wouldn't call those that oppose your bigotry "freaks".
You are free to believe whatever bullshit you want. You are free to marry, or not marry, whoever you want. How about you show some fucking decency and afford the same right to everyone else.
Your church will still be allowed to not marry same sex couples. You are free to limit your organization to those that agree with you, but the government has to be impartial and grant the same rights to everyone.
Last I checked, tough guy, we lived in a country that espouses equality for all. That means you don't always get your way, and that your views are not the end all be all. I don't care if you believe one-man-one-woman; IT'S NOT ALL ABOUT YOU OR PEOPLE WHO ONLY THINK LIKE YOU.
There are other people in the world besides white, straight christians. Get over it.
While I say everyone has the right to be in love and marry however they want... who do these people think they are telling anyone else who they can donate money to when they are throwing money at the groups they support. The double standard is unbelievable. I am not a religious person but I believe they have the right to live by their beliefs and donate to whomever they wish same as the LGBT community.
So you would be fine if I donate money to groups that try to make laws that women can't get abortions? That women can't drive? Hold public office? Can't leave the house, even for food, unless accompanied by a male relative? Now, other than the abortion one, no one in the US is trying to do these things. But in a country where everyone is supposed to have equal rights, why would you tolerate someone trying to take yours away? Why would you turn away from confronting that person or group?
Because when someone donates money to a group that supports the death penalty for gays in other countries, that's creepy.
But don't worry. They're just good christians who want their say. Right?
“Those Christian groups don’t see themselves as hateful organizations – it’s a completely different perspective,” said Rusty Leonard, a financial adviser who counsels Christians on charitable giving and who knows the Cathy family.
Hey, we all see a movie star when we look in the mirror. Doesn't mean Hollywood is on the phone....
CNN is Censoring posts again! Ahhh, what else is new?!
You said, "CNN is Censoring posts again! Ahhh, what else is new?!"
CNN uses WordPress blogs for their opinion pieces, and they use automated censoring that looks for words, or fragments of words, that are considered offensive. If your post doesn't show up, it most likely had a forbidden word in it.
On the Belief Blog, repeat posts, even those that were previously censored and not displayed, will show a message stating that you posted it before.
The following words or word fragments will get your post censored (list is incomplete):
arse as in Arsenal
cock as in cockatiel
coon as in cocoon
cum as in circumstance
homo as in homosexual
poo as in spooked
rape as in grape
sex as in homosexual
spic as in despicable
tit as in constitution or title
vag as in vague
To circumvent the filters you can break up the words by putting an extra character in, like: consti.tution (breaking the oh so naughty "tit").
The hm sectual community needs to get over its persecution complex. It's not discrimination for society to maintain the definition of marriage the way it has always been in all cultures from the beginning of time. It's based on the laws of physics, in that it takes two people of the opposite gender to create human life. Changing the definition will not make fat people skinny, short people tall or weird people normal.
ignoring for an instant the complete historical fallacy you have there, what would you call denying someone their civil rights if not persecution?
Uh...you have no idea what you're talking about. In 5 minutes of research, the definition of marriage in all cultures for all time has not been one man, one woman.
Are you deliberately this ignorant? Or have you just given up and decided to believe whatever you're told?
A certain Presidential candidate in 2008 said almost the exact same thing as Dan Cathy regarding traditional marriage. Was he protested and called a biggot? No. He was elected into office by the same people currently in an uproar about a Christian company's CEO giving his (apparantly shocking) opinion about his values. If anyone hear would like to tell me how the two statements by the two men were different, I'd love to read it.
These lib tards are hypocrites, haters, racists, and don't have enough sense to know better. Some people just want to espouse hate while crying how mistreated they are... they have lost any credibility to their cause.
Bella, you're a silly, ignorant little fool. Wrapped in your own cute little world where what you believe must be okay and right and one size fits all.
Enjoy it, but realize it's not gong to last. The world is going to change, and neanderthals such as yourself are going to have to catch up.
Looks like a Mitt follower in true colours.
Hypocrites – all of you.
Bella, you're one of the biggest. And that's likely literal.
Subtle picture with the Do not enter sign in front. I wonder if they meant it that way. Yep, probably..wouldn't put it past them to have photoshopped it in. Wonder what would happen if we started doing boycotts on gay run businesses. Oh yeah, we would be labeled intolerant. But not them. Love the dual standard. Ok, you can start flaming me now...
@dfldude: that happens every day. Along with beatings, murder, etc.
The minute gay people start roaming around in groups beating and killing christians? Let me know, fool.
Just listened to US national anthem again during olympic:
And this be our motto: "In God is our trust."
And the star-spangled banner in triumph shall wave
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave
1. Which God does GLAAD trust? Not "bible-based" God I guess?
2. Is USA not a "land of free" anymore? GLAAD has the rights to vocally say their opinions, while others should just shut up?
Or, should we change the national anthem? Oh, and the "In God We Trust" in the dollar bill also needs to be changed?
You are out if your league dude. Go back to logic 101.
You said, "2. Is USA not a "land of free" anymore?"
As long as believers keep forcing their nonsense on everyone else, we'll never be truly free.
You said, "Or, should we change the national anthem? Oh, and the "In God We Trust" in the dollar bill also needs to be changed?"
Can we, please?
I believe the same as Chik fil a. If you don't have the same views and it bothers you that much go eat somewhere else. The scary part is when you have elected officials saying they are going to block business owners based on their views.
I think that Chick-Fil-A should be given the same rights as any business such as McDonalds, group such as KKK or individual such as myself. If we don't like their stance then don't buy their product.
Yeah! Wouldn't it be awful if we had politicians who wanted to block businesses that wouldn't allow blacks inside? Or block landlords who wouldn't rent to people with children? Or block neighborhoods that wouldn't let Jews own property? Wow–wouldn't that be just awful!
And wouldn't it be just horrendous if we had politicians who wanted to block private employers from firing you because of your religious beliefs (which, by the way, is something you choose to believe)?
So many Christians, so few lions.
ahaha and people say that christians hate? look in a mirror
"Do unto others..." Ben...
Look in the mirror? Grow a brain dude. Hating hate is not hate.
What about the chickens? Does Chick-fil-A care about how the chickens are treated? Just wondering . . .
CNN sure knows how to milk a story don't they.
You clicked on it bozo.
I went to Chick-fil-a for 2 days in a row now for lunch. It was great chicken sandwich and a bonus I dont have to worry about catching aids from any if the sick gays.
uninformed troll is fail
D-bag. You need not worry. No gay would have the slightest interest in you dude.
Why don't the people who support gay rights just choose to eat somewhere else? Why does Chick-fil-A have to conform to gay rights support groups' ideology? Live & let live. Obviously the anti-gay support groups haven't stopped people from being gay and the gay support groups haven't made that many converts so what's the problem?
They not only have the right to eat somewhere else, they also have the right to criticize Chic-Fil-A . Free speech, remember?
something that must be practiced by others but not by us
Practice what you preach, numbnuts.
I'm pretty sure tolerance doesn't mean keeping quiet in the face of programs that fight to make you a second-class citizen. Would you be tolerant of that?
I dont think intolerance includes protesting a behavior that kills 20% of the people who engage in it.
@Susie – what are you talking about? Do I dare ask?
I hate Chik-Fil-A because of their endorsement of any religion, regardless of the gay issue. I don't want them creating foster care programs that force kids to be Christian just to have food. Same with Carls Jr / Hardees. I don't want my money going to Christians.
Here is a crazy idea for you.....don't go to Chick-fil-a
I hate people like you, you are sick in the head, good luck, you need it badly...
@dude: here's a crazy idea–we also have the right to criticize chic-Fil-a. Remember that thing called free speech?
Dont' eat there?
What a moron...fostercare families cant force their children to be Christian, they would get thir licenses revoked.
something that must be practiced by others but not by us
post it again please-no one's buying it-maybe if you post it a third time...
To everyone--why do you all care what the Chick-Fil-A guy thinks about gay marriage? His opinion affects NOBODY....at all! Are you all bored? Just ignore it if it bothers you. Sheesh opposition to anything gay seems to rustle everyones jimmies.
It's funny how the same thing is going on in reverse – gays come out in protest and everyone else is up in arms about that too. Both sides need to tone down the fight, but if one comes out and says bad stuff, they better expect the other to say bad stuff back. Just works that way.
And anytime someone criticizes the anti-gay goons, I bet you get your panties in a twist.